Handling Split-Locked Access in ACRN

A split lock is any atomic operation whose operand crosses two cache lines. Because the operation must be atomic, the system locks the bus while the CPU accesses the two cache lines. Blocking bus access from other CPUs plus the bus locking protocol overhead degrades overall system performance.

This document explains Split-locked Access, how to detect it, and how ACRN handles it.

Split-Locked Access Introduction

Intel-64 and IA32 multiple-processor systems support locked atomic operations on locations in system memory. For example, The LOCK instruction prefix can be prepended to the following instructions: ADD, ADC, AND, BTC, BTR, BTS, CMPXCHG, CMPXCH8B, CMPXCHG16B, DEC, INC, NEG, NOT, OR, SBB, SUB, XOR, XADD, and XCHG, when these instructions use memory destination operand forms. Reading or writing a byte in system memory is always guaranteed to be atomic, otherwise, these locked atomic operations can impact system in two ways:

Split-locked Access can cause unexpected long latency to ordinary memory operations by other CPUs while the bus is locked. This degraded system performance can be hard to investigate.

Split-Locked Access Detection

The Intel Tremont Microarchitecture introduced a new CPU capability for detecting Split-locked Access. When this feature is enabled, an alignment check exception (#AC) with error code 0 is raised for instructions causing a Split-locked Access. Because #AC is a fault, the instruction is not executed, giving the #AC handler an opportunity to decide how to handle this instruction:

  • It can allow the instruction to run with LOCK# bus signal potentially impacting performance of other CPUs.

  • It can disable LOCK# assertion for split locked access, but improperly makes the instruction non-atomic. (Intel plans to remove this CPU feature from upcoming products as documented in SDM, Volume 1, (Section 2.4 PROPOSED REMOVAL FROM UPCOMING PRODUCTS.)

  • It can terminate the software at this instruction.

Feature Enumeration and Control

#AC for Split-locked Access feature is enumerated and controlled via CPUID and MSR registers.

  • CPUID.(EAX=0x7, ECX=0):EDX[30], the 30th bit of output value in EDX indicates if the platform has IA32_CORE_CAPABILITIES MSR.

  • The 5th bit of IA32_CORE_CAPABILITIES MSR(0xcf), enumerates whether the CPU supports #AC for Split-locked Access (and has TEST_CTRL MSR).

  • The 29th bit of TEST_CTL MSR(0x33) controls enabling and disabling #AC for Split-locked Access.

ACRN Handling Split-Locked Access

Split-locked Access is not expected in the ACRN hypervisor itself, and should never happen. However, such access could happen inside a VM. ACRN support for handling split-locked access follows these design principles:

  • Always enable #AC on Split-locked Access for the physical processors.

  • Present a virtual split lock capability to guest (VMs), and directly deliver the alignment check exception (#AC) to the guest. (This virtual split-lock capability helps the guest isolate violations from user land).

  • Guest write of MSR_TEST_CTL is ignored, and guest read gets the written value.

  • Any Split-locked Access in the ACRN hypervisor is a software bug we must fix.

  • If split-locked Access happens in a guest kernel, the guest may not be able to fix the issue gracefully. (The guest may behave differently than the native OS). The real-time (RT) guest must avoid a Split-locked Access and consider it a software bug.

Enable Split-Locked Access Handling Early

This feature is enumerated at the Physical CPU (pCPU) pre-initialization stage, where ACRN detects CPU capabilities. If the pCPU supports this feature:

  • Enable it at each pCPU post-initialization stage.

  • ACRN hypervisor presents a virtual emulated TEST_CTRL MSR to each Virtual CPU (vCPU). Setting or clearing TEST_CTRL[bit 29] in a vCPU, has no effect.

If pCPU does not have this capability, a vCPU does not have the virtual TEST_CTRL either.

Expected Behavior in ACRN

The ACRN hypervisor should never trigger Split-locked Access and it is not allowed to run with Split-locked Access. If ACRN does trigger a split-locked access, ACRN reports #AC at the instruction and stops running. The offending HV instruction is considered a bug that must be fixed.

Expected Behavior in VM

If a VM process has a Split-locked Access in user space, it will be terminated by SIGBUS. When debugging inside a VM, you may find it triggers an #AC even if alignment checking is disabled.

If a VM kernel has a Split-locked Access, it will hang or oops on an #AC. A VM kernel may try to disable #AC for Split-locked Access and continue, but it will fail. The ACRN hypervisor helps identify the problem by reporting a warning message that the VM tried writing to TEST_CTRL MSR.

Disable Split-Locked Access Detection

If the CPU supports Split-locked Access detection, the ACRN hypervisor uses it to prevent any VM running with potential system performance impacting split-locked instructions. This detection can be disabled (eventually by using the ACRN configuration tools) for customers not caring about system performance.